Del.icio.us Digg FURL FaceBook Stumble Upon Reddit SlashDot

Pages: 1 [2]
« previous next »
Print
Author Topic: Favorite Shipwrecker  (Read 1591 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
lioness
Jr. Member
**

Karma: 1
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 152
« Reply #15 on: Apr 27, 2009, 02:52 »
Hermonie IS one of the most caring and considerate ones and for her to get annoyed about something MUST be bad ,which in my opinion Hollie promising nominating for one week only and that she'd be back only to find out that after four days ,mainly with Adam she'd pledged her allegiances to sharks ,so she was prepared to throw all those weeks of close friendships with Hermonie and Silkie for a lad [Adam] whom she'd only known for a few days and no i don't think they came across as bullies ,they just wanted to know why and were understandably miffed that it even crossed her mind to abandon them after making a tiger promise ,they obviously felt like she'd totally disregarded them whilst on sharks after only 4 days when they'd been through the entire journey for 8 weeks ,i'm glad they managed to sort things out but tbh i don't feel the same as i used to about hollie ,i still like her but not like i used to if that makes any sense and it pains me to have to say that as she was one of my favourites along with Hermonie
Logged
Island-Freak
Newbie
*

Karma: 0
Offline Offline

Posts: 12
« Reply #16 on: Apr 27, 2009, 05:46 »
Quote from: lioness on Apr 27, 2009, 02:52
Hermonie IS one of the most caring and considerate ones and for her to get annoyed about something MUST be bad ,which in my opinion Hollie promising nominating for one week only and that she'd be back only to find out that after four days ,mainly with Adam she'd pledged her allegiances to sharks ,so she was prepared to throw all those weeks of close friendships with Hermonie and Silkie for a lad [Adam] whom she'd only known for a few days and no i don't think they came across as bullies,

I can't agree, if you'd listened to Hollie talking about Adam in last week's episode she mentioned that they had got on very well when he was on Tiger island so they had already developed a friendship before she ventured over to Sharks, obviously that friendship grew much stronger during her time with the Sharks which seemingly lead to her being trapped between her commitment to the Tigers and her new found bond with Adam, it can happen, just because she was close with Hermione and co first doesn't mean she can't form just as close a relationship with anyone else (i.e Adam) , she also claims that she wasn't a fan of some of the Tiger guys actions so there was also other factors involved, as for Liam and Hermoine today, i thought it was so "jerry springer" like, just foolish drama really, they inferred that she was "negative" but yet they couldn't wait to drag her back to the Tigers, even using Adam as bait, instead of being happy that they'd got her back they adopted bully tactics just because she dared to put her own feelings before theirs, it was ridiculous imo and that's why i didn't like that episode.
Logged
werahellzabooze?
Full Member
***

Karma: 2
Offline Offline

Gender: Female
Posts: 260
« Reply #17 on: Apr 27, 2009, 12:15 »
Quote from: Island-Freak on Apr 27, 2009, 05:46
I can't agree, if you'd listened to Hollie talking about Adam in last week's episode she mentioned that they had got on very well when he was on Tiger island so they had already developed a friendship before she ventured over to Sharks, obviously that friendship grew much stronger during her time with the Sharks which seemingly lead to her being trapped between her commitment to the Tigers and her new found bond with Adam, it can happen, just because she was close with Hermione and co first doesn't mean she can't form just as close a relationship with anyone else (i.e Adam) , she also claims that she wasn't a fan of some of the Tiger guys actions so there was also other factors involved, as for Liam and Hermoine today, i thought it was so "jerry springer" like, just foolish drama really, they inferred that she was "negative" but yet they couldn't wait to drag her back to the Tigers, even using Adam as bait, instead of being happy that they'd got her back they adopted bully tactics just because she dared to put her own feelings before theirs, it was ridiculous imo and that's why i didn't like that episode.

Hollie herself has explained on the episode guide thread her reasons for nominating back to Tigers and it had nothing to do with her supposed "relationship" with Adam.
Logged
Tigers 2006
Tigers 2007
Tigers 2008
Sharks 2009
elle
Full Member
***

Karma: 12
Offline Offline

Posts: 384
« Reply #18 on: Apr 27, 2009, 13:06 »
Quote from: lioness on Apr 27, 2009, 02:52
Hermonie IS one of the most caring and considerate ones and for her to get annoyed about something MUST be bad ,which in my opinion Hollie promising nominating for one week only and that she'd be back only to find out that after four days ,mainly with Adam she'd pledged her allegiances to sharks ,so she was prepared to throw all those weeks of close friendships with Hermonie and Silkie for a lad [Adam] whom she'd only known for a few days and no i don't think they came across as bullies ,they just wanted to know why and were understandably miffed that it even crossed her mind to abandon them after making a tiger promise ,they obviously felt like she'd totally disregarded them whilst on sharks after only 4 days when they'd been through the entire journey for 8 weeks ,i'm glad they managed to sort things out but tbh i don't feel the same as i used to about hollie ,i still like her but not like i used to if that makes any sense and it pains me to have to say that as she was one of my favourites along with Hermonie

This post should be in Hermione's section and not in Hollie's.

Hermione was not caring and considerate when she suggested that Hollie was the sole cause of the Tigers discontent and that while Hollie was off the island the atmosphere on Tigers improved.

It is true that the atmosphere improved. That was because Hollie had voiced what was causing her to to leave for a holiday. Silkie used that information and lectured the boys about their laddish behaviour. The boys were also repremanded for stealing food. This behaviour was negative and disloyal and caused much disharmony. This all happened while Hollie was off the island. They then cleared the air and made great efforts to win Stacey. Stacey returned to Tigers early, of course making them all feel happy with their achievement.

It was not true Hollie caused the bad atmosphere. It was the boys. They were negative with new arrivals. Boys stole Rosie. It was Hollie voicing her concerns that made the Tiger's pull their socks up and improve the atmosphere. The boys did not like being repremanded, Hollie who was on the other island was instrumental to the bad atmosphere it caused.

When Hollie returned she was unjustly blamed for all the unhappiness.

Hermione wants to nominate.
http://www.channel4.com/services/videoplayer/popup.jsp?name=e09_gossip

Jack wants to nominate
http://www.channel4.com/services/videoplayer/popup.jsp?name=Bromance

Hollie had a good time on Sharks which made it hard for her to go back to Tigers. Ultimately she was loyal she returned and received a good kicking.

Tom's blog is interesting.

http://www.channel4.com/programmes/shipwrecked/articles/toms-tiger-blog

Sounds like he and Hermione had a very happy time when Hollie was away.
He is one that is not unfamiliar with double standards when it comes to disrespect and it seems Stacey was a real catch.
Logged
I'm not a newbie anymore
Taffy Nomad
Newbie
*

Karma: 0
Offline Offline

Posts: 32
« Reply #19 on: May 7, 2009, 11:36 »
I agree that Hermione was a bit harsh - she should have been pleased that Hollie changed her mind about staying on Sharks.  Why try to convince her to come back at the beach party if it had been so great without her?
Logged
Pages: 1 [2]
Print
« previous next »
Jump to: