Too a certain degree i tend to agree with you sirius however the fact that miss out large chunk of what people want to see for example a good 10 mins or so used to be ddicated to beach parties showing tribe members trying to sway new arrivals to either Sharks or Tigers theres none of that this year just a quick snipet of them getting off the boat then straight to them deciding which island they want to live on just gets right on my goat !!

The edditing hasnt been as bad as all that. Hollie at Greg and Maz's wedding is a big c*** up ill grant you that, but other than that there hasnt been too many noticable balls ups.

I did notice the week Dan was a new arrival they showed him admiting to having a crush on Xanthi and Xanthi saying no chance. But Dan despite being a new arrival was wearing his tribal neck lace so it was abviously taken from a latter week. But the way they eddited it made it seem like Dan was crushing on Xanthi right from the get go, which was maybe a bit miss leading. I can see why they did it though, cause I did think "ouch poor Dan"

As for the intro sequence I watch on delay and fast forward that bit, I always have done. But I do remember complaints last year that they gave quite a bit away. Not so sure on 2007 and 2006. But this year becuase of the whole stealing thing just because you see some one wearing a Tiger or Shark necklace it dosent mean that they chose that island or that they stay there.

HAHA werahellzabooze!! I knew it - when I watched it back I was like, blimey, did I say that in my first week. I was like, I'm sure I said it after a while when I got to know him a bit more cause I mentioned seeing people in a different light as I got to know them. The lil buggers - made a fool of me haha. In fact, when I was on tigers Hermionie asked me who I liked and I said no one, but did they show that, no. Xanthi has teased me about that for ages so I'm glad you cleared that up - very observant. Thanks

i know but i just prefer to see things as they happen ,and no i'm not always for sacking everyone as soon as they make a mistake ,but i do agree they should do a better job next year or alter future editing and Dan i thnk you made it perfectly clear you wasn't  fan of the tigers but i was surprised by your island law i thought you was gonna pick something outrageous ,even i was annoyed that week ,they seemed to be more concerned about greg nominating than trying to woo you ,oh i dunno it did seem a weird atmosphere glad you and xanthi got together

yeah i know i got that impresson that you and the lads didn't hit it off and i did feel sorry for you ,i wasn't knocking your sland law and i do understand you wanted them to try and get silkie to overcome her demons about killing the chicken ,i know your intentions were good and it must be lonely out there the 1st few days especially if you don't feel like you fit in ,even though i like tigers i was annoyed at the lads that week anyway you seemed to have got what you wanted from your experience on sharks as i'm sure everyone did on both islands ,i wouldn't wanna leave it looks so idyllic and trnquil out there

I agree Pipster i dont understand why the feel they need a new twist each week, Looking back the third idland twist was good but that because we got to watch the shipwrecked 3rd island show dedicated to it so in a sence got to know every one that went there. For me there doesnt need to be a new twist every week just one new arrival and an enphasis on building a community for 5 months should saffice for me anyway.