I have just watched 2006 again. I only remembered the bare bones so when the contestants chose their island I couldn't remember precisely their choice. The first time I saw 2006, over the twenty weeks, I wanted the Tigers to win, possibly because they wanted to win with more desperation.
Having watched it over a few days

I felt the Sharks definitely deserved to win. They attracted more people to their island and were able to keep them.
Starting out on the islands is very hard work and not an easy experience for both tribes. Sharks started out with strong minded, vocal people who didn't get on well. Geoff outcast himself and eventually nominated. He was not accepted by Tigers because two of them did not want him on their island.
One of them was Chris Baddu who went on to nominate himself to the Sharks for a short period. Chris himself expressed wanting to leave on occasion. He struck up and ended a relationship with an other member with the tribe causing that member to consider nominating.
Shark Kevin nominated himself to the Tigers for a short while. During his time there, Tigers kidnapped a Shark member. The Sharks invaded to rescue their Shark.
The punishment for both islands was a permanent swap.
It was a strange swap. Kevin who was originally a Shark (planning to return) was swapped for John who was an original Shark.
Even thought the rule break was instigated by Tigers, they were not punished apart from having to endure John on their island. Some Tigers also questioned wether John should receive a portion of Tigers winnings, he not wanting to be there, he therefore did not contribute to the Tiger cause. John was contributing to the Tigers win being a number against the Sharks and they winning the money.
I thought that was was poor. He should have received a prize either way, though in the whole scheme of the experience the money meant little to John, he just wanted Sharks to win the game.
Had the last contestant decided on the Tigers it would have morally resulted as a draw.
Sharks were winners they overcome many obstackles inter personality wise ie. James George became a valued member. He was out cast on the Tigers. Geoff outcast himself. He put himself up for nomination and was not accepted by two of the Tigers. He left the island later to be replaced by his sister who chose Sharks.
There were winners on Tiger island too. The builders Crawford and the other original who's name I forget. Crawford and Charlie (the posh one) who came over as very caring. Charlie on both islands.
Shipwrecked is a fantastic experience. The competition is entertainment for the viewers but essentially is a mar on the Islanders experience. But then the show is not about paradise. It's about people and how they react.
Having watched this again it seems that Shipwrecked 2009 draws much from 2006. The kidnappings, the island swapping. Though in 2009 the swapping is compulsory.